[SCG] SCG Evaluation

[Bill Hubbell]

Phil,

There are always folks who will make a competition out of anything.  Yes, 
you are correct that some may try to do what you just said, but that is 
their business, not ours.  SCG will not be officially releasing any "scores" 
(or whatever) to anybody but the owner of the car.  What the owner does with 
his worksheet is out of our control, but the intent is to gather the 
information, not to make comparisons.

Now, I think our time might be better spent focusing on other issues.

Bill Hubbell


----- Original Message ----- 
From: "P.H. Raker" <n556p at yahoo.com>
To: "Richard W Thompson" <Richard.W.Thompson at usa.dupont.com>; "Larry 
Claypool" <mr.vair at urbancom.net>
Cc: <scg-list at tiger.skiblack.com>; <scg-list-bounces at tiger.skiblack.com>; 
"Bill Hubbell" <whubbell at umich.edu>
Sent: Wednesday, July 12, 2006 10:57 AM
Subject: Re: [SCG] SCG Evaluation


Bill, Larry, Rich,
     I'm not disagreeing with you.  I agree that this should be a
non-competitive event.  What you say does, however, raise a question.
Unfortunately, any sort of "score" attached to the evaluation could be
considered by some to be "competitive".  If there is no "score" to the
evaluation, how does the owner of the car being evaluated know how
stock his car is?  Would the only generate a list of "discrepancies"
(non-stock items found)?  Even that could be considered by some as a
competition. ("My list is shorter than yours.")

Phil Raker
'65 Corsa 140 (restored)